Courts Split over Interest on Unsecured Claims in 100% Chapter 13 Plans
On an issue where the lower courts are about evenly divided, Bankruptcy Judge Basil H. Lorch, III of Evansville, Ind., ruled that a chapter 13 debtor who is not devoting all disposable income to the plan can confirm the plan by paying unsecured creditors in full, without interest.
The debtor would have disposable income of more than $80,000 over the course of the proposed five-year plan. Timely filed proofs of unsecured claims amounted to some $17,000, and payments under the plan would total about $51,000. Although the chapter 13 plan would pay unsecured claims in full, the debtor was not proposing to pay interest on unsecured claims.
The chapter 13 trustee objected to confirmation, contending that Section 1325(b)(1) requires interest on unsecured claims. The trustee argued that the statutory language in subsection (b)(1), “as of the effective date of the plan,” modifies the word “value” in subsection (b)(1)(A) to mean that the plan must pay the present value of the claims and therefore includes interest.
Also relying on Section 1325(b)(1), the debtor contended that unsecured creditors are not entitled to interest. The debtor interpreted the quoted language as modifying both subsections (A) and (B) by specifying the date when the court must make the calculation.
Listing decisions coming down on both sides, Judge Lorch said in his September 13 opinion that the courts are “equally divided.” The Norton and Collier treatises take opposite positions on the outcome, with Collier on the debtor’s side.
Judge Lorch adopted the approach of Bankruptcy Judge Thomas L. Perkins of Peoria, Ill., in In re Gillen, 568 B.R. 74 (Bankr. C.D. Ill. 2017).
Related Stories
April 9, 2024
Title: The Alarming Rise of Identity Theft: A 2024 Perspective In recent years, the threat…
July 27, 2022
IRS Fresh Start Initiative Program, resolving IRS tax debts. Do You Need a Fresh Start…
June 9, 2022
IRS First Time Penalty Abatement – FTA The first-time penalty abatement (FTA) waiver is an…
March 26, 2022
If you filed a chapter 7 bankruptcy, look into filling IRS form 982 When you…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
March 26, 2022
DID SOMEONE FILE FOR UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS UNDER YOUR NAME? If you discover that someone has…
February 3, 2022
RICO suit, McKinsey In a decision last week, the Court of Appeals for the Second…
December 17, 2021
BEWARE OF USING MONEY FROM YOUR IRA OR 401(K) TO PAY DEBTS This can be…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
December 17, 2021
How to Spot Student Loan Scams. Things you can do to protect yourself. “Enroll now…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
April 9, 2024
Title: The Alarming Rise of Identity Theft: A 2024 Perspective In recent years, the threat…
July 27, 2022
IRS Fresh Start Initiative Program, resolving IRS tax debts. Do You Need a Fresh Start…
June 9, 2022
IRS First Time Penalty Abatement – FTA The first-time penalty abatement (FTA) waiver is an…
March 26, 2022
If you filed a chapter 7 bankruptcy, look into filling IRS form 982 When you…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
March 26, 2022
DID SOMEONE FILE FOR UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS UNDER YOUR NAME? If you discover that someone has…
February 3, 2022
RICO suit, McKinsey In a decision last week, the Court of Appeals for the Second…
December 17, 2021
BEWARE OF USING MONEY FROM YOUR IRA OR 401(K) TO PAY DEBTS This can be…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
December 17, 2021
How to Spot Student Loan Scams. Things you can do to protect yourself. “Enroll now…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy