Red-Light Camera Revenue and Safety Impact in Nassau County: What You Need to Know

Nassau red-light camera revenue

Understanding Nassau’s Red-Light Camera Program and Its Impact

Nassau County’s red-light camera program generated $64 million in revenue in 2022, marking a 23% increase compared to two years earlier. This revenue spike makes it the third-highest total in the program’s 15-year history. With 308 cameras installed at 100 intersections, the program aims to reduce traffic incidents and improve safety. However, concerns about the program’s financial implications remain.

The program’s ticket fines include a $50 base fee, a $45 “driver responsibility fee,” and a $55 “public safety fee,” totaling $150 per violation. While no points are added to a driver’s license, critics argue that these fees act as a “backdoor tax,” burdening motorists beyond what is necessary for safety. Proponents, however, emphasize the program’s role in reducing dangerous accidents, such as T-bone collisions, which decreased by 76% at red-light intersections since 2009.

Revenue Breakdown and Safety Outcomes

In 2022, revenue from red-light cameras came from various sources: $25.3 million from the “public safety fee,” $18.7 million from the “driver responsibility fee,” and the remainder from base fines and late fees. Despite concerns about its costs, the program has led to fewer rear-end crashes (down 4%) and injury-related accidents (down 33%).

Supporters of the program believe it enhances safety, while critics see it as more of a revenue mechanism. In fact, one source highlighted that if safety were truly the goal, violations and revenue would decrease over time. Instead, the program consistently brings in substantial income, which fuels skepticism.

Suffolk County’s Approach: A Different Strategy

While Nassau County’s red-light program remains active, Suffolk County decided to phase out its own by the end of 2022. Suffolk’s cameras generated $17.5 million in revenue last year, but controversy surrounding fees led to a significant change. After a State Supreme Court ruling declared a $30 administrative fee unconstitutional, Suffolk eliminated it, reducing the total fine to $50.

The decision to end Suffolk’s program came after state lawmakers failed to extend it during the 2022 legislative session. This shift highlights ongoing debates about the best approach to balancing driver safety with fair financial practices.

The Future of Nassau’s Red-Light Camera Program

The debate over Nassau’s red-light cameras continues. Legislation to extend the program for another five years was recently approved, ensuring its continuation until at least 2027. As the program evolves, critics and supporters alike will keep a close eye on its impact on both revenue and driver behavior.

How Red-Light Cameras Operate

Red-light cameras in Nassau capture images and video of vehicles running red lights. Positioned 50 to 150 feet before the stop line, these cameras document violations and send the evidence to the registered motorist. Although they effectively catch violators, only a small number of tickets are contested in court. Of the nearly 500 challenges in 2022, only about 54 were dismissed.

Despite the program’s intent to enhance road safety, its cost to drivers cannot be overlooked. Legal battles, such as a lawsuit filed by a motorist challenging the fees as “unauthorized taxes,” suggest that the controversy surrounding the program is far from over.

Our law firm offers expert legal guidance to ensure your rights are protected, whether you’re contesting a ticket or seeking broader legal support. Contact us today for a consultation and let our experience work for you.


CLICK HERE to view books published by Attorney Ronald S. Cook

CLICK HERE to contact the law firm.