How a Criminal Record Can Impact Your U.S. Citizenship Application

Criminal Record U.S. citizenship application

How a Criminal Record Can Impact Your U.S. Citizenship Application

Pursuing U.S. Citizenship with a Criminal Record

If you are seeking U.S. citizenship and have a criminal record, understanding how this may affect your application is crucial. Demonstrating “good moral character” is a key requirement for naturalization. A misdemeanor or felony conviction could jeopardize this, depending on the type of crime and its severity.

Good Moral Character and U.S. Citizenship

U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) evaluates the moral character of applicants over a five-year period—or three years if married to a U.S. citizen. A misdemeanor can be a red flag, questioning whether you meet the good moral character standard. While misdemeanors are less severe than felonies, some offenses like theft, violence, or crimes involving moral turpitude may pose serious challenges.

Criminal Bars to Naturalization

Certain crimes can permanently disqualify you from naturalization. Aggravated felonies, for example, are automatic barriers. Even some misdemeanors could complicate your application, especially those involving dishonesty or violence. USCIS also holds discretion to deny citizenship if a crime reflects poorly on your moral character, especially if you have multiple offenses.

How Criminal Convictions Affect Immigration Status

If you are not a U.S. citizen, criminal convictions may lead to more severe consequences than you think. Arrests, detainers, and even minor offenses like shoplifting or turnstile jumping can lead to detention, deportation, or rejection of a citizenship application. These consequences could arise even if the offense seems minor.

Fingerprinting and Immigration Holds

After an arrest, local police share your fingerprints with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). If ICE determines that deportation is possible, they may issue a detainer, holding you in custody even if you post bail. ICE may then arrest you for immigration violations once your criminal case concludes.

The Risks of an Immigration Detainer

In New York, ICE can be notified if you’ve been convicted of certain felonies, even after serving time. If ICE issues a detainer, your release may be delayed, and you could face deportation or prolonged immigration detention. Always consult with your lawyer to understand the full impact a detainer can have on your status.

What to Do If You Don’t Have Immigration Status

If you’re undocumented, overstayed your visa, or entered the U.S. without permission, an arrest can have devastating effects. A criminal conviction might permanently bar you from obtaining legal status, such as permanent residency, asylum, or U.S. citizenship.

Lawful Immigration Status Does Not Offer Complete Protection

Even if you are a lawful permanent resident or visa holder, certain criminal convictions can result in deportation or the loss of immigration status. If convicted of specific crimes, you might lose the ability to renew your green card or change your status, including pursuing citizenship. Discuss with your lawyer how to best approach your case to avoid these consequences.

Applying for Citizenship with a Criminal Record

Even if you have a misdemeanor on your record, it may still be possible to pursue U.S. citizenship. However, you must carefully evaluate the impact of your offense on the good moral character requirement. Waivers or appeals may be an option depending on the circumstances of your case, but you should not attempt to hide your criminal history. Transparency is key when navigating the citizenship process.

Preparing a Strong Application

To increase your chances of a successful outcome, it’s essential to work with an experienced immigration lawyer. Gather all relevant documents, including police reports, court records, and character references. Demonstrate how you’ve reformed and made positive contributions to society since the incident.


Take Action Today

If you’re concerned about how a criminal charge might affect your U.S. citizenship application, don’t wait. Our law firm specializes in helping individuals with criminal records navigate the complex path to U.S. citizenship. Contact us today to schedule a consultation. We will provide the guidance you need to protect your rights and move forward with confidence.


Contact our law firm today to schedule your comprehensive consultation and take the first step towards realizing your immigration goals. With our expert team by your side, your journey to the U.S. is in capable hands.

CLICK HERE to visit the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services website.

CLICK HERE to view books published by Attorney Ronald S. Cook

CLICK HERE to contact the law firm.

immigration law firm